Incogni vs. OneRep: Which Data Removal Service Actually Protects Your Privacy?

(And Why More People Are Choosing DeleteMyInfo in 2025)

Let’s be honest: privacy online isn’t what it used to be.

Your personal information—name, address, phone number, maybe even your family members—is probably sitting on dozens (or hundreds) of sketchy websites right now. People-search directories, data broker lists, spam databases. You name it, you’re probably on it.

That’s where data removal services like Incogni and OneRep come in. They promise to clean up your digital footprint and help you take back some control. But how well do they actually work in 2025? And is there a better alternative?

Let’s compare them—and see why more people are moving to DeleteMyInfo for full-spectrum privacy protection.

Incogni vs. OneRep

🧩 Incogni: Simple, Automated, and Very Hands-Off

Incogni is basically the “set it and forget it” option in the privacy world. Built by the team behind Surfshark VPN, it’s designed for people who want to offload the work of contacting data brokers without thinking too hard about it.

You give them permission, and they send removal requests to over 200 brokers. That’s about it.

What It Gets Right:

  • It’s really easy to use—no privacy expertise needed

  • One of the most affordable options out there

  • Sends automated takedown requests to a decent list of brokers

  • Clean interface with basic progress reports

Where It Falls Short:

  • Doesn’t remove anything from Google

  • No custom takedown help for blogs, PDFs, or personal mentions

  • No dark web monitoring

  • Lacks live support or personalized assistance

  • If you want more features, you’ll need their “Ironwall” plan (and good luck finding transparent info on it)

Verdict: Good for beginners who want to dip their toes into privacy without spending much—but don’t expect deep cleanup.


⚡ OneRep: Fast and Focused on Brokers (And Only Brokers)

OneRep goes a little harder than Incogni—especially when it comes to speed. Once you sign up, it instantly starts scanning the internet for your personal data, hitting 200+ people-search sites and public data brokers.

The idea? Get in fast, get it removed, and keep scanning to catch it again if it reappears.

What People Like:

  • Very fast, always-on removal system

  • Covers a lot of broker websites in the U.S.

  • More aggressive about monitoring changes

  • Affordable pricing, especially for families and small teams

What’s Missing:

  • Still no Google cleanup—you’re on your own there

  • No help with reputation cleanup or negative content

  • No custom support for takedown requests outside of their list

  • Fully automated—there’s no human touch for tricky removals

Verdict: If your only concern is people-search sites, OneRep’s a solid option. But it stops short when it comes to content cleanup, search results, or anything personal.


✅ DeleteMyInfo: The Privacy Service That Actually Covers Everything

Here’s the problem with Incogni and OneRep: both are good at one thing, but leave out a whole lot of other stuff.

That’s why people who want real privacy protection are turning to DeleteMyInfo.

Instead of limiting you to just brokers—or making you upgrade to get Google help—DeleteMyInfo includes everything upfront. No feature gates. No hidden “premium” tiers. Just full coverage, plain and simple.

What Makes It Different:

  • Unlimited data broker removals

  • Google search clean-up included—not extra

  • Unlimited custom requests: blog posts, PDFs, cached pages, you name it

  • Reputation repair help for people dealing with old or harmful content

  • Dark web monitoring, so you know if your info’s floating around where it shouldn’t be

  • Dedicated human support, not just automation

  • Supports up to 10 people per plan

  • Starts at just $120/year

“I didn’t have to figure out what level of protection I could afford. I just got all of it. Period.”


🔍 Quick Comparison: Incogni vs. OneRep vs. DeleteMyInfo

FeatureIncogniOneRepDeleteMyInfo
Broker Site Removal~210 sites200+ sites✅ Unlimited
Google Search Clean-Up❌ Not included❌ Not included✅ Included
Custom Takedown Requests❌ Not offered❌ Not offered✅ Unlimited
Reputation Management❌ None❌ None✅ Included
Dark Web Monitoring❌ None❌ None✅ Included
NDNC Opt-Outs❌ None❌ None✅ Included
Live Human Support❌ Fully automated❌ Fully automated✅ Yes
Price (Annual)$99 – $359+$99 – $180$120 – $900
People Covered1–5 maxUp to 61–10 (flat plans)

💡 Final Thoughts

  • Incogni is a decent starting point—great if you’re on a budget and just want to be off broker lists.

  • OneRep is faster and more thorough on brokers, but still ignores Google, dark web leaks, and anything outside its list.

  • DeleteMyInfo is the only one that does it all—search engine cleanup, broker removal, custom takedowns, reputation support, and dark web monitoring—with flat pricing and no gimmicks.

In a world where your private info spreads like wildfire, the best privacy protection is the one that doesn’t hold back.

And that’s exactly what DeleteMyInfo delivers.

Brief comparison of Data Removal Services in 2025 and how DeleteMyInfo™ stands out.

Who is better?

Find out which DATA BROKERS sell your Personal Information!

Logo

Your message has been sent. Thank you for contacting us, we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.